Steven Spielberg's secret JAWS message to Hollywood hiding in plain sight
Steven Spielberg’s Jaws (1975) is more than just a suspenseful thriller about a killer shark terrorizing a New England beach town. Beneath its surface swims a potent cultural metaphor for a seismic shift in American cinema. At its heart, Jaws stages a symbolic battle between the fading ideals of Old Hollywood and the insurgent vision of New Hollywood, with its three central characters—Quint, Hooper, and Brody—serving as embodiments of these competing forces. Quint represents Old Hollywood: grizzled, mythic, and masculine. Hooper symbolizes New Hollywood: educated, technical, and subversive. Brody, the everyman caught between them, is the audience whose loyalty both sides seek. The shark, then, is not just a creature—it is change itself, devouring the past and testing the relevance of each ideology in turn.
Quint: The Ghost of Old Hollywood
Quint is a walking archetype, a throwback to the rugged individualist heroes of John Ford and Howard Hawks films. He's self-reliant, hyper-masculine, disdainful of authority and academia. He refuses to use modern technology unless it suits him, scoffing at Hooper’s sonar equipment and high-tech shark cages. His methods are old-school: he sings sea shanties, crushes beer cans with his bare hands, and recounts war stories with haunting gravity, most notably the USS Indianapolis monologue—a scene that anchors him firmly in a World War II-era moral universe.
Quint’s rejection of collaboration and modernity parallels the decline of the Old Hollywood studio system, which by the 1970s had lost its grip on American film culture. Like the aging stars and auteurs of that era, Quint is increasingly irrelevant in a world that no longer works according to the rules he understands. His final demise—mauled by the very shark he tried to conquer through brute force—symbolizes the fatal limits of Old Hollywood’s mythmaking and individualism. He dies clutching his machete, consumed by a force he underestimated, just as Old Hollywood was overtaken by a wave of new directors, new stories, and new audiences.
Hooper: The Face of New Hollywood
In contrast, Hooper is a product of the modern age. Young, affluent, and college-educated, he represents the New Hollywood filmmaker—technically proficient, influenced by European cinema, and eager to challenge traditional tropes. He brings gadgets, cameras, and skepticism aboard the Orca. He doesn’t see the shark as a monster to be slain but as a biological anomaly to be studied and understood. His presence is disruptive to Quint, whose masculinity is threatened by Hooper’s intellect and unflinching defiance.
Hooper’s survival, especially after diving into the water to face the shark in a steel cage, suggests that New Hollywood, while not invincible, is better equipped to adapt to the unpredictable forces of the industry. He disappears temporarily, giving the illusion of defeat, only to resurface after Quint is gone and the shark is destroyed. The metaphor is clear: though mocked and marginalized by the old guard, New Hollywood endures and emerges to tell the tale.
Brody: The Audience in Transition
Chief Brody, caught between these two extremes, is neither a man of tradition nor of innovation—he is simply a man trying to make sense of the chaos. A city cop relocated to a small town, Brody is out of his element both on land and at sea. He lacks Quint’s bravado and Hooper’s expertise, making him an ideal stand-in for the audience: unsure of which narrative to follow, which method to trust, and which worldview to believe.
In the final act, it is Brody who kills the shark—not through strength or science, but through improvisation, grit, and a bit of luck. His climactic act of blowing up the shark with a rifle and an air tank isn’t rooted in old-fashioned heroism or scientific precision—it’s a desperate, middle-of-the-road gamble. The fact that Brody, not Quint or Hooper, delivers the final blow reinforces the idea that the audience, not the filmmakers, ultimately decides what stories survive. And by siding with Brody—cheering his victory—we the audience validate the hybrid filmmaking ethos that Jaws itself represents: a high-concept blockbuster with auteur sensibilities.
Jaws occupies a unique position in film history. It is both a product and a catalyst of change. On one hand, it marked the beginning of the modern blockbuster era, signaling the studio’s return to box office dominance through spectacle and merchandising. On the other hand, it carried the creative fingerprints of a young director who was part of the New Hollywood movement—a movement born from rebellion against the very system Jaws would help redefine.
Through the symbolic clash between Quint, Hooper, and Brody, Spielberg stages a generational struggle for cinematic soul. Old Hollywood dies with a snarl; New Hollywood dives into murky waters but survives. And the audience—ever adaptable, ever curious—rides the waves of change. In the end, Jaws is not just a film about a shark. It’s a film about the industry itself, struggling to navigate uncharted waters. And like Brody, we all just want to get back to shore.
If you would like to write for The Daily Jaws, please visit our ‘work with us’ page
For all the latest Jaws, shark and shark movie news, follow The Daily Jaws on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook.
