How to make the perfect shark movie

Shark movies hold a unique place in cinematic history. They often blend suspense, fear, and awe into stories of survival, showcasing the ocean’s most feared predator. The perfect shark movie strikes a delicate balance between tension, realism, and thrill, capturing audiences' imagination and tapping into primal fears. But what specific elements combine to create a truly memorable and terrifying shark movie? By examining some of the most iconic films in the genre, like Jaws, The Shallows, and Deep Blue Sea, we can identify the key components that define the perfect shark movie.

1. Suspense and Tension

Suspense is the lifeblood of any successful shark film. The lurking threat of a shark beneath the water, often unseen, builds psychological tension. In Steven Spielberg's Jaws (1975), the audience doesn't fully see the shark until later in the film, allowing fear to fester through suggestion and anticipation. This technique keeps viewers on edge, unsure when or where the predator will strike. The eerie, minimalistic score by John Williams heightens the tension further, creating an atmosphere of dread.

The ability to keep viewers in suspense is also central to the success of films like The Shallows (2016), where a lone woman’s fight for survival against a massive shark unfolds over a few hundred feet of ocean. The distance between safety and danger feels tangible, and every minute of her battle creates nail-biting tension. The slow buildup of terror is essential in a shark movie, keeping audiences engaged and on edge

Steven Spielberg employed a 'sharks-eye-view' in JAWS to help build tension

2. Believable Characters and Emotional Stakes

A perfect shark movie requires characters that viewers care about. When characters are fully fleshed out, their survival feels more personal, raising the stakes. In Jaws, the three protagonists—Chief Brody, shark expert Matt Hooper, and Quint, the seasoned fisherman—each have distinct personalities and motivations. Their interplay and camaraderie, as well as their individual vulnerabilities, create an emotional connection that heightens the tension as they confront the great white shark. The same holds true for The Reef (2010) and 47 Meters Down (2017), where survival feels more urgent because the characters are portrayed as ordinary people in extraordinary, life-threatening circumstances.

In Open Water (2003), the emotional depth of the central couple’s relationship makes their plight all the more harrowing. As they float in the middle of the ocean, their dialogue and fears give weight to their ordeal, making the audience feel every moment of their desperation.

Quint's experience on the USS Indianapoils reveals his hatred of sharks

3. A Terrifying and Plausible Threat

The portrayal of the shark itself is crucial. A shark movie succeeds when the predator is not only menacing but also somewhat grounded in reality. Part of what made Jaws so terrifying was the plausibility of a rogue great white terrorizing a beach town. Spielberg’s restrained use of the shark, coupled with the realistic behavior of the creature, helped the audience suspend disbelief and lean into the terror.

While some films, like Deep Blue Sea (1999), push the boundaries with genetically engineered sharks, the best shark movies maintain some semblance of realism. Even in more fantastical entries like Bait (2012), where sharks invade a flooded supermarket after a tsunami, the central threat of a shark in close quarters remains rooted in the plausible fear of being hunted by an apex predator. When sharks behave like real animals—driven by hunger and survival—it adds to the fear factor, as audiences can more easily imagine themselves in similar peril.

The shark towing the broken jetty demonstrates it's power and determination in JAWS

4. Isolation and Environment

The setting is a vital element in a shark movie’s success. The ocean itself acts as both a physical and psychological barrier, adding layers of tension to the plot. The open, endless expanse of water in films like Open Water and The Reef emphasizes the vulnerability of the characters. In these films, survival isn’t just about avoiding the shark; it’s about battling the elements and the sheer hopelessness of being isolated in the vast sea. This feeling of isolation amplifies the terror, making viewers feel trapped alongside the characters.

Films like The Shallows cleverly use more confined environments, such as a lone rock surrounded by water, to create a more intimate kind of terror. Similarly, Under Paris (2024) takes the shark threat into the claustrophobic tunnels beneath a city, offering a new twist on the isolation theme. In both cases, the environment limits the characters’ ability to escape, and the sharks are not just predators but obstacles that stand between the characters and their salvation.

In The Shallows (2016), the main character was cut off from land by the shark and had to use all her ingenuity to stay out of the water

5. Visually Striking Cinematography

A perfect shark movie relies heavily on its visual storytelling. The underwater scenes need to be immersive, drawing the viewer into the dangerous beauty of the ocean. Films like The Shallows and 47 Meters Down use cinematography to create a striking contrast between the stunning natural beauty of the ocean and the lurking menace beneath the surface. Sunlit waters and vast, tranquil seascapes create an eerie sense of calm before the inevitable storm.

Kon-Tiki (2012), while not a traditional shark thriller, uses breathtaking ocean cinematography to enhance the tension during its shark attack scene. The visuals of the raft surrounded by endless ocean, with sharks circling underneath, convey a deep sense of dread. In shark films, the ocean is not just a setting; it’s a character in itself—vast, indifferent, and full of hidden dangers.

Showing the vastness of the ocean made the Orca look small and fragile, depsite the egos onboard

6. Innovation and Fresh Ideas

Finally, the perfect shark movie finds ways to innovate within the genre. As shark movies have evolved, filmmakers have experimented with different plot structures and settings to keep the concept fresh. Under Paris takes the shark horror genre out of its usual environment, bringing it to an unexpected setting beneath a city. Meanwhile, Deep Blue Sea added a sci-fi twist with genetically modified sharks, providing a more action-packed take on the genre.

Innovation can also come in the form of focusing on realism and survival, as seen in films like Open Water and The Reef, which are stripped down and gritty. This willingness to reinvent the core elements of the shark movie keeps the genre exciting and allows it to evolve.

In Deep Blue Sea (1999) the Mako sharks were deliberately made smarter to help cure human disease with dire consequences

The perfect shark movie combines suspense, realism, emotional depth, and innovative settings to create an unforgettable experience. Whether it's the primal fear of being hunted by an apex predator or the heart-pounding tension of survival in an unforgiving environment, shark movies captivate by turning the ocean into a dangerous playground where humans are no longer at the top of the food chain. Films like Jaws, The Shallows, and The Reef show that with the right balance of character, setting, and threat, a shark movie can be as thrilling as it is terrifying.

If you would like to write for The Daily Jaws, please visit our ‘work with us’ page

For all the latest Jaws, shark and shark movie news, follow The Daily Jaws on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook.