Extremely rare for these waters: Why did the shark in JAWS choose Amity Island?

In Steven Spielberg's iconic film "JAWS," the menacing presence of a great white shark terrorizes the tranquil shores of Amity Island. While the narrative revolves around the harrowing struggle between man and nature, a fundamental question emerges: Why did the shark choose Amity as its hunting ground? Delving beyond the surface, exploring the shark's behavior, environmental factors, and the unique characteristics of Amity Island may reveal the explanation for the predator's choice. So, here’s why the shark in JAWS may have chosen to claim a stake to the waters off Amity Island….

Abundance of Prey

Amity Island, being a popular tourist destination and a fishing community, offers a smorgasbord of potential prey for the shark. Tourists flock to its beaches, providing a steady stream of unsuspecting swimmers and divers. Fishermen, drawn to the rich waters teeming with marine life, add to the buffet with their catches. Furthermore, the bustling activities around the island, such as boating and water sports, increase the likelihood of encounters between humans and the shark, presenting ample opportunities for attacks.

Ideal Habitat

The coastal waters surrounding Amity Island likely boast a diverse ecosystem, with abundant marine life serving as a primary food source for the shark. The nutrient-rich environment supports a variety of fish species, attracting sharks seeking to capitalize on the abundance of prey. Additionally, the underwater topography, including reefs, shoals, and deep channels, provides ideal hunting grounds for the shark to ambush its unsuspecting victims while utilizing the terrain to its advantage.

Warm Waters

Sharks, being ectothermic creatures, rely on external sources of warmth to regulate their body temperature. The temperate climate and warm waters surrounding Amity Island provide an inviting habitat for the shark, ensuring optimal conditions for its survival and activity. The mild winters and warm summers maintain the water temperature at levels suitable for the shark's physiological needs, allowing it to thrive year-round without the need to migrate to warmer waters during colder seasons.


The shark likely chose Amity due to a combination of favourable conditions, Great White sharks are dependant upon a healthy marine environment in order to establish themselves as an apex predator in those locations. Amity’s fictional location likely boasts an abundance of prey - enough to draw the shark in, water temperatures within the tolerable range for white sharks and an ocean topography suited for ambush hunting. All this paired with a shark needing to opportunistically feed at regular intervals, especially considering its apparent consumption of nutrient-poor human bodies.
— Kristian Parton, shark scientist and host of 'Shark Bytes'

Geographic Isolation

Amity Island's geographical isolation, surrounded by water and accessible primarily by ferry, serves as a natural barrier that limits human interference and predator competition. The island's remoteness restricts the movement of potential threats to the shark's dominance in its territory, minimizing conflicts with other marine predators and reducing the risk of human intervention in its hunting activities. This isolation affords the shark a sense of control and security over its environment, enabling it to establish dominance as the apex predator within the island's coastal waters.

Opportunistic Behavior

The shark in "JAWS" exhibits opportunistic behavior, driven by its instinctual need to feed and survive. Its choice of Amity Island as a hunting ground is less a calculated decision than a response to the abundant food sources and favorable environmental conditions present in the area. As an apex predator, the shark exploits opportunities as they arise, capitalizing on the abundance of prey and the absence of significant threats within the island's waters. Its relentless pursuit of food stems from a primal instinct ingrained in its nature, compelling it to seek out vulnerable targets and assert its dominance in the marine ecosystem surrounding Amity Island.

From the abundance of prey to the isolation of the island, from the dynamics of human intrusion to the thematic resonance of the setting, each aspect contributes to the gripping narrative that has captivated audiences for decades. Ultimately, the shark's choice reflects not only its primal instincts but also serves as a potent metaphor for the fragility of human safety in the face of nature's relentless power. As the waves of Amity's waters continue to churn, the legacy of the shark's ominous presence endures, reminding us of the enduring allure and terror of the deep blue sea.

Watch: Could a Great White shark the size of 'Jaws' really exist?

Like King Kong, the shark in Jaws (1975) is a real life species, still existing today (only just). It’s not from outer space or an abandoned science experiment gone wrong (that we know of). So is a Great White shark the size of 'Jaws' possible? Ross from The Daily Jaws is joined by shark expert Kristian Parton to try and answer that very question.

Article inspired by AmbroRiver on IG.

Words by Ross Williams

If you would like to write for The Daily Jaws, please visit our ‘work with us’ page

For all the latest Jaws, shark and shark movie news, follow The Daily Jaws on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook.